The best 5 Goalies of all Time

Over the decades, the NHL has produced some of the finest goaltenders ever to grace the ice. Their reflexes, mental toughness, and ability to decide games have made them legends. In this blog, we take a look at the top 5 NHL goalies of all time. Who are the greatest, and why? Keep reading to find out.

1. Martin Brodeur – The Ironman

No name is as closely associated with consistency and success as Martin Brodeur. With an incredible 691 wins, he still holds the record for the most victories by an NHL goaltender.

Why is Brodeur a legend?

• Playing Style: Brodeur was known for his versatility. His ability to play the puck and act as a "third defenseman" revolutionized goaltending.

Achievements:

• 3 Stanley Cups with the New Jersey Devils (1995, 2000, 2003)
• 4-time Vezina Trophy winner (best goaltender)

Statistics:

• 125 shutouts (also a record)
• Career goals-against average (GAA) of 2.24

Special Moment:

Brodeur’s performance in the 2006/07 season, where he won 48 games, will never be forgotten. His influence on modern goaltending is undeniable.

2. Patrick Roy – The Clutch King

Often referred to as "Saint Patrick," Patrick Roy was famous for his composure in crucial moments. With 4 Stanley Cups, he is one of the most successful goalies of all time.

What made Roy so special?

• Playing Style: Roy popularized the "butterfly style," where goalies drop to their knees to block shots.

Achievements:

• 3-time Conn Smythe Trophy winner (Playoff MVP) – a record for goalies
• 2 Stanley Cups with the Canadiens, 2 with the Avalanche

Statistics:

• 551 career wins
• Career GAA of 2.54

Special Moment:

Roy led the Colorado Avalanche to a Stanley Cup in their inaugural season (1995/96). His charisma and confidence made him a fan favorite.

3. Dominik Hašek – The Dominator

Known as "The Dominator," Dominik Hašek is synonymous with spectacular saves and incredible reflexes.

Why is Hašek in the top 5?

• Playing Style: Hašek's unorthodox and unpredictable style made him extremely difficult for attackers to beat.

Achievements:

• 6 Vezina Trophies – a record for European goaltenders
• 2 Hart Trophies (MVP) – rare for goalies
• 2 Stanley Cups with the Detroit Red Wings

Statistics:

• Career GAA of 2.20
• 81 shutouts

Special Moment:

His legendary playoff saves in 1999 for the Buffalo Sabres remain unforgettable. Despite an underdog team, Hašek carried the Sabres to the Stanley Cup Final.

4. Jacques Plante – The Innovator

Jacques Plante is often regarded as a pioneer of modern goaltending. He was the first goalie to consistently wear a mask—a move that forever changed the game.

Why was Plante so influential?

• Playing Style: Plante was a tactical goaltender known for his positioning and game sense.

Achievements:

• 6 Stanley Cups with the Canadiens
• 7-time Vezina Trophy winner

Statistics:

• 437 career wins
• Career GAA of 2.38

Special Moment:

On November 1, 1959, Plante became the first goalie to wear a mask during a game after sustaining a facial injury. Although initially met with resistance, his decision became the norm.

5. Terry Sawchuk – The Classic

Terry Sawchuk is one of the most iconic figures from the early NHL. With 103 shutouts, he held the record for decades until Brodeur surpassed it.

What makes Sawchuk special?

• Playing Style: Sawchuk was a traditional goalie known for his discipline and focus.

Achievements:

• 4 Stanley Cups
• 4-time Vezina Trophy winner

Statistics:

• 447 career wins
• Career GAA of 2.52

Special Moment:

Sawchuk’s impressive 44-win rookie season (1950/51) remains a highlight in NHL history.

Honorable Mentions

Besides the top 5, other goalies have also earned their place in history:

• Ken Dryden: The brilliant short-career goalie with 6 Stanley Cups in just 8 seasons.
• Glenn Hall: The "Iron Man" of goaltenders, playing 502 consecutive games.

What Makes an NHL Goalie a Legend?

The greatest goalies are defined by a combination of technique, mental strength, and the ability to excel in critical moments. Each of the goalies mentioned shaped the game in their unique way and set standards for future generations.

Conclusion

Discussions about the best NHL goalies will always be subjective, as every fan has their own criteria. However, players like Martin Brodeur, Patrick Roy, and Dominik Hašek changed the game and will never be forgotten.

If you're a hockey goalie yourself, check out our custom goalie sticks. Available in all colors and sizes, with names at unbeatable prices.

Who's your favorite goalie? Share it in the comments!